Blogs

Peer-to-peer (P2P) fundraising is an essential skill for every nonprofit professional. Successfully running these campaigns helps you deepen relationships with supporters, introduce your cause to new audiences, and build social proof. But once a P2P campaign ends, the next step is translating that momentum into long-term engagement.

In this post, we’ll cover four strategies for turning one-time P2P events into recurring annual fundraisers that drive donor acquisition and retention. Put these strategies into practice and get ready to transform your fundraising results.

1. Bridge the Gap Between Event and Annual Giving

Many nonprofits treat peer-to-peer campaigns as standalone events, whether P2P walk-a-thons, fun runs, or team challenges. While planning the main event for your fundraiser is important, your follow-up plan is key to keeping donors engaged — especially for first-time donors. 

After your event, follow these steps to integrate new supporters from P2P campaigns into your annual fundraising efforts and turn them into repeat donors:

1. Segment new supporters: Separate donors acquired through P2P campaigns from your general donor base. Use donation amounts, giving methods, and basic prospect research to identify those most likely to give to your annual fund.

2. Share impact stories: Send personalized thank-you emails within 48 hours, highlighting the specific project your P2P campaign funded. Include testimonials and real stories that demonstrate the program’s impact.

3. Introduce the larger mission: Within a week of their donation, provide a brief, compelling overview of your mission to help new donors feel a connection to the cause itself, not just the individual who invited them to give.

4. Share low-effort ways to stay involved: In the weeks following the P2P event, send periodic emails or text messages with simple calls to action, such as following your nonprofit on social media, filling out a survey, or signing up for updates.

Treat peer-to-peer fundraisers as an entry point, not a final destination. New P2P donors are already motivated to learn about your cause – your immediate follow-up will determine if they stay connected. Thoughtful, targeted stewardship is key to improving new donor retention.

2. Empower Supporters to Host DIY Campaigns

P2P campaigns don’t have to revolve around a signature event or even be led by your nonprofit. Add more flexibility and increase annual giving potential with year-round DIY (do-it-yourself) fundraising opportunities. 

DIY fundraisers are often launched by passionate supporters to celebrate personal milestones, such as a birthday, or to memorialize a loved one. Instead of asking their friends and family for birthday gifts, supporters ask their networks to donate to your organization on their behalf.

However, DIY fundraising doesn’t have to be tied to an occasion. Empower your supporters to launch campaigns at any time, for any reason, by:

• Providing clear, simple instructions for launching a DIY fundraiser through your nonprofit’s website or the supporter’s social media accounts.

• Promoting your supporters’ DIY fundraisers on your website and social media page.

• Offering fundraising toolkits that include images, sample social media posts, and appeal templates.

• Highlighting supporters who dedicate personal life events to your cause.

Whether powered by a dedicated peer-to-peer platform or free social media tools like Facebook birthday fundraisers, the key is clarity. Make it easy for supporters to launch a successful DIY campaign.

3. Ask Top P2P Participants to Become Ambassadors

Another way to turn peer-to-peer participation into year-round engagement is to start an ambassador program. Invite your most active online supporters to share content, promote campaigns, and advocate for your mission year-round. Your nonprofit provides guidelines and support, and the ambassadors use their influence to amplify your reach.

Peer-to-peer campaigns often reveal supporters with a unique ability to lead others (whether they’re actual social media influencers or not), making them the perfect candidates for your ambassador program.

Use campaign analytics to identify top participants, such as those who raised the most funds, had the most page visits, or recruited the most donors. Reach out with personalized invitations outlining your ambassador program and the impact they could make by joining. Provide clear guidance, and encourage them to start sharing right away to help drive more donations for your annual fund.

4. Use Gamification to Drive Year-Over-Year Retention

To strengthen your peer-to-peer fundraising, start your campaign planning early. Build your strategy for engaging current P2P participants using gamification and incentives to encourage year-over-year contributions.

For instance, you might:

• Create special digital badges for returning participants that celebrate repeat participation and recognize their multi-year commitment to the cause.

• Keep public leaderboards active after the campaign to spark competition among corporate teams or community groups.

• Visualize individual and organization-wide progress with live thermometers to show how the collective community effort is advancing your annual goals.

These tactics help you maintain excitement long after the fundraiser ends. Pair gamification with personalized, impact-focused recognition to ensure supporters feel appreciated and inspired to stay involved.

Harness the Power of P2P for Your Annual Fundraising Today

Developing any new fundraising skill takes time, but you can start turning P2P momentum into long-term giving today. 

To get started, review your nonprofit’s most recent P2P campaign data and identify first-time donors who haven’t engaged since the fundraiser. Then, create a tailored outreach and stewardship plan that reconnects them to your mission and highlights meaningful ways to stay engaged. The sooner you tap into this energy, the more likely new supporters are to become long-term contributors.