Blogs

4 Key Metrics Your Nonprofit Should Share With Donors

By Dionna Dash posted 9 days ago

  

Your donors care about your mission, and they likely want to hear from your organization outside of your year-end appeals. By sending regular updates and reports that show supporters how you use their contributions, you can maintain donor trust and strengthen your relationships over time.

The most effective stewardship reports go beyond generalities and provide useful data about how your donors power your nonprofit’s progress toward its mission. In this guide, we'll explore four metrics you should share with donors to establish transparency and effectively communicate your nonprofit’s impact.

1. Revenue & Expenses

Being open about your nonprofit's finances holds your organization accountable and shows donors that you are a responsible steward of their gifts. Supporters want to know where their money goes, so include revenue and expenses in your report to answer their finance-related questions before they even have to ask.

Implement the following practices to effectively share financial information with donors:

  • Break down revenue and expenses by category. Sorting your figures into categories helps donors better understand how your organization raises and allocates funds. For example, you might divide revenue into grants, annual campaign revenue, investment dividends, and program revenue, and group expenses into categories like program costs, fundraising, and administrative or overhead costs.
  • Incorporate data visualization. Visual elements make your report easier and more engaging for your donors to read. Use data visualization, such as donut charts, bar graphs, and pie charts, to illustrate your funding breakdown. Be sure to add a legend to any chart or graph you include so that supporters understand what they're looking at.
  • Link to additional information. Provide more context for curious donors. Consider using donor stewardship software to create online reports that link to more detailed financial documents, such as your Form 990. This way, supporters can then access more information if they'd like, while your report stays streamlined and easy to read.

Beyond maintaining transparency with donors, regularly tracking and documenting your financial information keeps your nonprofit compliant and audit-ready. Ultimately, an audit-ready organization is a trustworthy one, giving supporters the ultimate peace of mind that their contributions are in safe, capable hands.

2. Outputs & Outcomes

Donors want to know what their gifts accomplish, and sharing both outputs and outcomes gives them a full picture of their impact. Outputs cover what your organization did, such as serving 70 meals to people in your community or rescuing and vaccinating 60 cats. Outcomes emphasize what your efforts made possible, such as helping 30 families recover from food insecurity or finding homes for 40 of those 60 cats.

Rather than simply listing them, experiment with engaging ways to highlight each metric. For instance, you can showcase outputs with animated statistics or an infographic in an online report. To highlight outcomes, consider including a story from a beneficiary or member of your program staff to incorporate a heartfelt narrative about the difference your nonprofit’s work makes.

It's also wise to include the cost per outcome, such as the cost of finding a home for one cat, to tie your results back to what your donors make possible through their gifts. Showing the impact of donations helps supporters feel assured that your organization puts their contributions to good use.

3. Donor-Specific Information

Encourage additional gifts and make donors feel seen by highlighting their impact in your reports. Sharing information about their gifts and interests shows donors where they fit into your work and that your team pays attention to what matters to them.

To show donors their impact in your stewardship communications, include:

  • Total amount raised, broken down by campaign. Help your donors see their collective impact by sharing the total amount your organization raised with each campaign. Including this metric in your report also demonstrates that your organization is paying attention to which programs and messaging resonate most with supporters.
  • The size and reach of your donor community. Include the total number of donors, along with specific counts of recurring and new donors, to foster a sense of community among people who choose to support the same cause. You might also add a map or infographic showing your supporters' geographic reach to illustrate how people across the country and around the world contribute to your impact.
  • Specific gifts that made program outcomes possible. Consider including a couple of deeper dives into major gifts and how they powered your organization's work. This provides interested major donors with greater visibility, but make sure you have their permission before sharing their stories, since some choose to remain anonymous.

To demonstrate an additional level of care for your donors, consider personalizing your stewardship communications. The right reporting software can help you add donors’ names and gift amounts to each report by pulling data from your CRM, enabling you to personalize at scale without adding manual work to your team’s plate.

4. Impact Stories

Qualitative metrics are just as important as the numbers you share with your donors. Your supporters give because they want to support your mission, so you should reinforce the connection between your work and real-world impact. To add greater depth and emotional resonance to your stewardship communications, pair your data with compelling storytelling.

Incorporate a narrative component to your nonprofit's reports by taking these steps:

  • Consider your audience. Different donor segments may respond to different stories, so think about which narratives to include in which communications. For instance, a major donor might want to hear how their scholarship fund improved a beneficiary's college experience, while a monthly donor might appreciate hearing from your staff about how their support helps with daily operations.
  • Include photos and videos. Visual storytelling adds a face to the stories about your organization's impact. Look for dedicated software for engaging donors with a story collection tool, so you can keep your photos and videos organized and drag and drop them into your reports.
  • Connect your stories to the future. For each story you include, tie the results back to your mission and explain how your donors' continued support will contribute to similar outcomes going forward.

While a donor may find a statistic interesting, they are more likely to remember it if it is tied to a larger story. Lean on the link between narrative and memory to keep your organization top of mind for supporters and motivate them to continue giving.

To begin sharing these metrics with your supporters, evaluate your current data management practices and report-building process. Look for a digital report builder that lets you collect impact stories year-round and pull data from your CRM, making it easy to create engaging communications. After you send out your report, analyze a few more metrics for your internal use. Track opens, time spent reading, and clicks on calls to action in your report to see how your communications land with donors and continue to refine your efforts.

0 comments
11 views

Permalink